| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| May 17 2026 | CF Pachuca (Pk) at Pumas UNAM (Pk) (CF Pachuca (Pk) +100) | loss |
| May 17 2026 | Chicago at Minnesota (Chicago +5.5) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Cleveland at Detroit (Detroit -4.5) | loss |
| May 17 2026 | Columbus at Birmingham (Birmingham -3.5) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Cremonese 0,+.5 at Udinese 0,-.5 (Udinese 0,-.5 +108) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Kansas City at St Louis (Kansas City +107) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | LA Dodgers at LA Angels (LA Dodgers -139) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | LA FC 0,+.5 at Nashville SC 0,-.5 (Nashville SC 0,-.5 -115) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Las Vegas at Atlanta (Atlanta +3.5) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | NY Yankees at NY Mets (NY Mets -117) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Port Timbers +1.5,+2 at Inter Miami -1.5,-2 (Inter Miami -1.5,-2 -105) | Win with Push |
| May 17 2026 | Real Betis +1.5 at FC Barcelona -1.5 (FC Barcelona -1.5 -115) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | San Francisco at Athletics (San Francisco +133) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Seattle at Indiana (Seattle +11.5) | WINNER |
| May 17 2026 | Toronto at Los Angeles (Toronto +7.5) | WINNER |
|